Nana insists this 4 ingredient wonder is the reason grandpa married her. I whipped it up in 5 minutes yesterday and completely understand why.

desired, top each piece with a little extra whipped topping or a thin lemon slice for a simple finishing touch.

Slice of creamy lemonade pie served cold on a dessert plate
Finished creamy lemonade pie professionally plated with coffee and fresh berries

Variations & Tips

Extra Lemony: If your family likes a brighter citrus flavor, add 1 teaspoon of finely grated lemon zest to the filling. It gives the pie a fresher taste without changing the easy nature of the recipe.

Lemonade pie variation topped with fresh lemon zest

Frozen